Consultancy · Research & Publications

Bringing human interaction to electronic trading.

Exploring how enhanced instant messaging could support discussion, negotiation and structured transaction execution in commodity derivatives markets.

Rory McCarthy · MSc dissertation · University of Liverpool · 2010

Back to Consultancy

Research overview

The dissertation, A Proposed Instant Messaging (IM) Platform for Adding Human Interaction to E-Trading (Electronic Trading) within the Base Metal Commodity Derivatives Markets, was submitted on 12 June 2010. It investigated whether an extended messaging platform could bring conversational interaction together with the structured functions of electronic trading.

Electronic venues offered speed and access to liquidity, but complex transactions could still require clarification, negotiation and specialist judgement. The research examined that gap from both business and technology perspectives.

Objectives

  • Understand where human interaction contributed to the transaction process, particularly when requirements went beyond standard trades.
  • Compare telephone, instant messaging and electronic trading across discussion, transaction construction and execution.
  • Identify the usability, technical, security and compliance capabilities an enhanced messaging platform would require.

Methodology

The work used an empirical case study centred on base metals trading, with comparisons across other commodity markets and input from external industry participants. It combined a literature review, surveys, practitioner interviews and observation of trading activity.

The research mapped the transaction lifecycle and decision points, then used a functional gap analysis to compare existing communication and trading channels with a proposed enhanced messaging platform. Survey responses and follow-up discussions helped interpret preferences and practical constraints across trading, client-facing and supporting roles.

Principal findings

  • Conversation retained an important role. Participants valued telephone and messaging interaction for discussing and structuring complex transactions. Preferences varied by task and market; electronic execution remained valuable for speed and liquidity.
  • Messaging offered useful flexibility, with trade-offs. Written conversations and concurrent discussions were useful, but ambiguity, disrupted message sequencing, missed messages and limited screen space could affect usability.
  • Chat alone left functional gaps. An enhanced platform would need clearer transaction actions and confirmation, links to trading and risk systems, and support for downstream processing.
  • Trust and operational reliability were central. The proposal identified strong authentication, encrypted communication, central archiving, monitoring, availability and latency as important design considerations.
  • Adoption depended on the wider community. Customer and counterparty preferences influenced platform choice. Interoperability, access, cost and organisational policies mattered alongside functionality.

Conclusion and scope

The dissertation concluded that an enhanced messaging platform could be a useful addition to the tools used by traders and client-facing teams. Its contribution was a requirements-led proposal combining human communication with more structured transaction support.

This was an exploratory case study and design proposal, rather than evidence of a completed, deployed or experimentally validated platform. The findings reflect the participants, technologies and market conditions examined in 2010 and should not be read as a description of today’s trading systems or requirements. High-frequency and algorithmic trading were outside the study’s scope.

About this synopsis

This public synopsis summarises the research at a general level. Company and client identities, participant details, interview transcripts, internal figures, system configurations and commercially sensitive material have been omitted. The original dissertation is not published or available to download here.

Research informed by practical experience.

Explore the consultancy background behind this work.

Explore Consultancy